Download Our Toolbar


toolbar powered by Conduit

Wednesday, March 28, 2007

An Opposing View

Opposing views are welcomed here. I am not a member of the Silence Committee of the Taliban.

The Legacy of Slavery Hustle by Walter Williams

Summary: I doubt whether the reparations gang could develop a coherent theory of the generation-skipping effects of slavery. Vestiges and legacy of slavery arguments are simply covers for another hustle similar to the $6 trillion dollar War on Poverty hustle.

Today, there are increasing numbers of black professionals and scholars advocating reparations for slavery. New York Times staff writer Tamar Lewin, in her June 3 article "Calls for Slavery Reparations Getting Louder," says that a team of black lawyers have announced that they plan to sue the federal government and companies that have profited from slavery.

Slavery was an abomination. There's no argument, based on morality, that can justify slavery and its attendant evils. Indeed, were it possible, slave traders and slave owners should be forced to make reparations to those whom they enslaved. A similar case cannot be made for reparation payments to slave descendants.

Adjoa Aiyetoro, a legal consultant to the National Coalition of Blacks for Reparations in America, says, "We're not raising claims that you should pay us because you did something to us 150 years ago. We are saying that we are injured today by the vestiges of slavery, which took away income and property that was rightfully ours." This vestige-of-slavery argument, as an explanation for the pathology seen in some black neighborhoods, is simply nonsense when you think about it.

Illegitimacy among blacks today is 70 percent. Only 41 percent of black males 15 years and older are married, and only 36 percent of black children live in two-parent families. These and other indicators of family instability and its accompanying socioeconomic factors such as high crime, welfare dependency and poor educational achievement is claimed to be the legacy and vestiges of slavery, for which black Americans are due reparations. Let's look at it.

In 1940, illegitimacy among blacks was 19 percent. From 1890 to 1940, blacks had a marriage rate slightly higher than whites. As of 1950, 64 percent black males 15 years and older were married, compared to today's 41 percent.

In Philadelphia, in 1880, two-parent family structure was: black (75.2 percent), Irish (82.2 percent), German (84.5 percent) and native white Americans (73.1 percent). In other large cities such as Detroit, New York and Cleveland, we find roughly the same numbers.

According to one study of black families (Herbert G. Gutman, "The Black Family in Slavery and Freedom, 1750-1925"), "Five out of six children under the age of 6 lived with both parents."

That study also found that, in Harlem between 1905 and 1925, only 3 percent of all families were headed by a woman under 30 and 85 percent of black children lived in two-parent families. The question raised by these historical facts is: If what we see today in many black neighborhoods, as claimed by reparation advocates, are the vestiges and legacies of slavery, how come that social pathology wasn't much worse when blacks were just two or three generations out of slavery? Might it be that slavery's legacy and vestiges have a way, like diabetes, of skipping generations? In other words, for example, that devastating 70 percent rate of black illegitimacy simply skipped six generations -- it's a delayed effect of slavery.

I doubt whether the reparations gang could develop a coherent theory of the generation-skipping effects of slavery. Vestiges and legacy of slavery arguments are simply covers for another hustle similar to the $6 trillion dollar War on Poverty hustle.

Interestingly enough, reparations advocates are not demanding that white people be taxed in order to send checks out to individual black people. What they're demanding is for money to be put into a reparations fund from which they decide who receives how much for what purpose. (Actually there is a call for both, like one individual claiming he will file a reparations claim for you so you can get $500,000 from the U.S. Government. Just pay him $50 to do it. -- Ed.)

For me, that has just as much appeal as the Rev. Leroy's call for people to send their money to him and he'll send it to God.
http://www.blackamericaweb.com/site.aspx/sayitloud/phillips927?view=Forum

No comments:

Evidence for God from Science

Commentary -- Click Lower Right Black Bar to Play, Click Middle Black Bar to Pause

TELL A FRIEND ABOUT CHITTLIN' TALK

Please support this site by clicking the ads and the Marketplace Links. Thanks.
Find the Perfect Gift on eBay!

Videos on Darfur, Sudan

Loading...

BlackMag BlackHistory

Booker T. Washington said:

"There is another class of colored people who make a business of keeping the troubles, the wrongs, and the hardships of the Negro race before the public. Having learned that they are able to make a living out of their troubles, they have grown into the settled habit of advertising their wrongs -- partly because they want sympathy and partly because it pays. Some of these people do not want the Negro to lose his grievances, because they do not want to lose their jobs....There is a certain class of race-problem solvers who do not want the patient to get well, because as long as the disease holds out they have not only an easy means of making a living, but also an easy medium through which to make themselves prominent before the public."

BlackMag BlackFacts

BlackMag Black

BlackMag BlackHeroes

BlackMag BlackPeople

BlackMag BlackIssues

BlackEnterprise.com Exclusive Headlines

Black Star Project in Chicago

BlackInformant.com

La Shawn Barber's Corner

Black Girl In Paris

blackpundit.com

Mary Mitchell

Black Entertainment News

123Greetings : Daily Celebrations

Black Entertainment : Black News : Urban News : Hip Hop News - EURWEB.com

BlackAthlete.com Stories

Roll cursor over the Token White Guy to get him to talk

Emerging Minds African American Culture Magazine

PewResearch.org | All Feeds

From:
To:
Departing:
Returning:
Adults (18-64)

Human Rights Watch News Releases, Africa

Black Looks -- Trafficking

AllAfrica News: Latest

Africa News latest RSS headlines - Africa Leader.com

SouthAfrica.info RSS feed

African News from World Press Review

BBC News | Africa | World Edition

Buzztracker.com - Barack Obama

Buzztracker.com - Al Sharpton

Regret the Error -- Errors and Fake News in the Media